Comparison post time!! If you're a pink-iac like me, you obviously need all four, but if you're not a huge pink lovah, maybe this will help you narrow the field.
Bottle shot! Left to right: Beauty Within, Pink Plumeria, Pink Voltage, Shocking Pink:
And here we have it in the same order on my hand: Beauty Within - pinky, Pink Plumeria, Pink Voltage, Shocking Pink - index finger
So there are some clear differences!
On my pinky, Beauty Within has some blue tones.
Pink Plumeria, on my ring finger, is peachier and has shimmer.
Pink Voltage, middle, is the most "bubblegum" or bright and also has a slight shimmer that you'll see better in the close up picture.
Shocking Pink, on my pointer finger is the lightest pink but dries fairly matte, like a true neon.
Yes, my cuticles aren't perfect...no hate mail, mmkay? :)
Here are a couple close-ups:
My middle finger has Pink Voltage, and you can see a very slight shimmer here:
Pink Plumeria stands out. Compared to the others, it is much more peachy, or even an orange/coral rather than pink. It also has a very apparent shimmer:
I also recently purchased Escaping Reality from the new Cirque collection, and just from the bottle comparison, it looks THISCLOSE to Beauty Within.
Updated comparison post coming soon!
Thanks for stopping by!